What's new
Roleplay UK

Join the UK's biggest roleplay community on FiveM and experience endless new roleplay opportunities!

Server admins: CSI Killerabbit abuse - Rage banning.

Status
Not open for further replies.

ARES

Member
In-game name: RONO MC ALVANOS

Your player ID (copy from your arma 3 profile):  76561198020906151

 

What was lost: ALL of my vehicles. Hours worth of work.

 

Value of item/money lost: HEMTT + Hummingbird + SUV + Rahim etc.

Quick description of what happened: 

First allow me to say that I regret that my first post on this forum has to be one of this nature. 

I really enjoy the roleplay experience that this server offers and do what is possible to remain within these boundaries that have been laid out by the admins and police.

HOWEVER - There seems to be people in the police force that think the rules are up to their own subjective interpretation. The following is what happened to me shortly before I was banned (and then unbanned after speaking with a very rude CSI Killerabit).

1. Me and my friend do a coke run in 2 HEMTT's. We are racing against the reset which is in 50 minutes.

2. A few minutes before reset we are intercepted by two police officers en route from the processing plant to Athira.

3. A chase ensues, I veered off road in order to try to pull the coppers from my friends HEMTT and only one (Killerabbit) pursues me.

4. After 5-10 MINUTES of offroad pursuit I hope the RP has kicked in and he has realized I am now allowed to fire on him as I am evading arrest and a card carrying member of the rebel forces. 

5. I stop my car and shoot him dead.  Immediately rage-banned.

I unforunately don't see this mod lasting very long due to immature behavior like this. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Are you still banned?

Do you have video evidence of the killing or someone in the same car as you that can act as a witness? 

I was only able to catch the last few mins of the chase with your friend and it all ending in athira (if its the same chase we are on about)

 
This was the first and only chase we have been in.

I was (almost immediately) unbanned after a listening to a brief tirade on how upset he was and then told to 'not do that again'.

My vehicles are missing from my garage after the ban. Apparently banning me wiped my character data.

As far as I know I didn't break any rules.

I don't run video recording software but I will now. My friend can verify, for what it's worth.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I know an admin will repeat me on this one, can you check today your garage and double check that the gear is actually missing.

Secondly the police have a new crush feature. So the hemmit you was driving full of durgs, may have been crushed and removed from your player. 

As for the other vehicles, over to the guys with godly powers. Hopefully i helped clear some stuff up here.  

Good to know you was unbanned and killer spoke to you. In the future to avoid potentially claims of RDM - as quick as you can text the police simply saying "I will shoot if followed" or something along those lines. If the cop is smart they will put the dispatch call together with the guy they are following and then the roleplay really has started. Obviously it can be hard to do as your currently driving away in a car chase. 

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Good to know you was unbanned and killer spoke to you. In the future to avoid potentially claims of RDM - as quick as you can text the police simply saying "I will shoot if followed" or something along those lines. If the cop is smart they will put the dispatch call together with the guy they are following and then the roleplay really has started. Obviously it can be hard to do as your currently driving away in a car chase. 
It's a bit far-fetched to expect a lone driver to text the police with warning.

The chase with the blues and twos activated has already started the roleplay scenario through both players actions (truck full of drugs, cops on the tail). He clearly doesn't want to get busted with a HEMMT full of drugs, so is going to do what he can to escape the wrath of the law.  This is the first I've heard of a police chase not being enough to instigate the role play so I don't understand the "don't do it again" attitude.

Cops have the taze first ask questions later option in all situations and in some scenarios, civs/rebels should have a shoot on sight (against the cops) approach - such as drug gathering, processing, trafficking without being accused of RDM.

 
No of course, that where the fine line or grey area so to speak is.

Just if you can do it, its only for your sake to cover you on the better side of the grey area. 

 
Yeah I see what you are getting at Mitch but from an admin/rule perspective this grey area should be made clear cut to avoid false claims of RDM and then the player wouldn't have to risk turning their vehicle into a fireball in order to cover their ass. I'd like to see the other admin's stance on this.

I'm not saying any cop with sirens/lights on should be KoS'd. But if they are chasing you and you have a lot to lose, then it should be seen as fair game and well within RP to pull over and shoot them, outside of a city (which it is AFAIK). Same goes for any cops raiding the drug areas.

It's the bit about ARES being told 'not to do it again' that worries me. In order for rules to be enforced, people must be aware of them. Hopefully an admin jumps on and clarifies it all.

 
Since the new rules cops are chasing ifrits more so than usaual so they can crush them if you stop, being that they are illegal everywhere.

So fear of losing said bullet magnet ppl are more likely to run and kill cops who try pulling over an ifrit.

Basic Causality .

 
Yes Nekromantis, it doesn't stop the vehicle but it means you have to wait for a long straight road to send it. Plus if you text a message as short as that to the whole police force, it has no context (vehicle type, general position) so would no doubt be ignored.

Cops should not bother to pursue a suspect unless they are prepared to die on duty.

Cops - Call in backup, keep safe distance, co-ordinate another unit to setup a roadblock/spike strip ahead of suspect, wait for a time to strike when they have the advantage. This is why cops would normally travel in pairs as one can relay to HQ the info, whilst the other focuses on driving.

 
Right so lets go through some things on this as you say immature however I would say lying is pretty immature. as far as the "rage ban", as you failed to mention in this post for some reason, we as you remember had a conversation about this, you were banned for intentionally stopping your vehicle with intention of RDMing, you shot me with no role play at all. As I explained to you the police have a new policy of chasing vehicles before we can shoot, and even then, with role play, if we must role play so must you. As far as you being a rebel, as I was shot before I even got out of the vehicle, I'm not sure how I'm suppose to know this, one of the issues with the rebels can RDM and one of the reasons its going to be changed. 

We had a conversation about this after the incident, in which I calmly explained the situation, you said sorry and assured me there would be no repeat of the incident, so your ban was lifted. 

As far as what you lost, and this is a huge lie, there was no humming bird and SUV anywhere near, so how you could be so delusional to put that down I don't know. Even in your story there is no chopper or SUV?? As far as your hemmit, I believe it was impounded, so you have that back, which I'm sure you know, and so long as you sync'd your data your Rahim wont have gone either. A second hemmit was stopped and I believe that was seized by the police, your not getting that back, as that was legally seized.

For future reference, it wasn't a rage ban and I wasn't rude. If I was being rude, I wouldn't have listened to your point of view, and you wouldnt have been unbanned.

Unfortunately I don't see myself unbanning you next time with this kind of immature behaviour... 

 
The hummingbird and SUV were inside my garage. When you banned me my garage and inventory was completely wiped. It seemed to be a pretty standard rage ban as it was instant, you were screaming at me immediately after i killed you ("CONGRATULATIONS YOU JUST EARNED A BAN") and there was no discussion until I instigated one.

I don't see the point in playing this game if there can't be a gunfight without a lame cops & robber role-play. In a real life situation like the one we created there would have been no verbal exchange between the two parties only bullets! There is really no excuse as the rules are listed in the forums and fairly specific, and if the rules have been changed as you say please change the rule posts in so we can be informed. 

From the police rules of engagement:

a) If a member of the police or a civilian is in immediate danger, lethal force may also be used. Lethal force may be used on persons, who are believed to be an immediate threat to people around them.

 
B) The use of lethal force needs to should be announced clearly at least once towards the suspect / target. Not applicable if the situation won't allow it.
 
 Notice it says these things only SHOULD be attempted, but not required if you are in immediate danger.

From the player rules about rebels:

V. Rebel gameplay

a) Only players with a rebel license are considered rebels and are allowed to follow "rebel business" like attacking cops in towns, etc. Players without a rebel license using firearms are considered RDMers. 

---

u. As far as you being a rebel, as I was shot before I even got out of the vehicle, I'm not sure how I'm suppose to know this, one of the issues with the rebels can RDM and one of the reasons its going to be changed. 
I put both of our lives in danger by running off the road. I did it deliberately in hopes you would crash or disable your vehicle. Pursuing me and being aware of these dangers I assumed you were also planning on using comparable or overwhelming lethal force to defend yourself and so I had no choice but to shoot you.

----

It's a military combat simulator, I don't see why there would be such a restriction on combat outside of towns, especially given the circumstances.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Firstly altis life is not a military simulator, if you want that go play wasteland, second this:

a) Only players with a rebel license are considered rebels and are allowed to follow "rebel business" like attacking cops in towns, etc. Players without a rebel license using firearms are considered RDMers. 

You were no where near a town. No where near. As far as your ban goes, yes, you earned your self an instant ban. I only gave you a 2 day ban, for you to learn, after talking to the admins they said I was in the wrong, I should have made it a PERMANENT ban, so I feel I was being quite generous. As for "screaming at you" you can ask anyone if have ever "screamed" at them, yes I was slightly irritated, and I said "congratulations you earned your self a ban". 

As for the things inside your garage, I will have a chat with Ed, but banning does not affect what you have in your garage, battle eye and the database are two totally separate entity's and have no interaction at all...

I would strongly suggest you drop this high and mighty attitude, your lies are not going to win you any favors.

 
Firstly altis life is not a military simulator, if you want that go play wasteland, second this:

a) Only players with a rebel license are considered rebels and are allowed to follow "rebel business" like attacking cops in towns, etc. Players without a rebel license using firearms are considered RDMers. 

You were no where near a town. No where near. As far as your ban goes, yes, you earned your self an instant ban. I only gave you a 2 day ban, for you to learn, after talking to the admins they said I was in the wrong, I should have made it a PERMANENT ban, so I feel I was being quite generous. As for "screaming at you" you can ask anyone if have ever "screamed" at them, yes I was slightly irritated, and I said "congratulations you earned your self a ban". 

As for the things inside your garage, I will have a chat with Ed, but banning does not affect what you have in your garage, battle eye and the database are two totally separate entity's and have no interaction at all...

I would strongly suggest you drop this high and mighty attitude, your lies are not going to win you any favors.
You better give him some aloe vera for that wicked burn. (i just wanted to say that)

 
Ergh. Toys back in prams, gentlemen, please.

Right. Some myths to dispel.

Banning someone does NOT change the database (and your stored vehicles or gear) in ANY way whatsoever. All we do is add your BattlEye GUID number to the BattlEye ban-list, so that it kicks you off the server if you attempt to join in future. That is *all*. If you have lost or don't have any item of equipment or vehicle after a ban, this is pure coincidence. We don't even update the database due to your DISCONNECTION from the kick... that only happens if you DIE (and that's generally considered RP, so will stand). Even then, vehicles never vanish due to death - only clothing, gear, guns, cash-in-hand, etc.

Vehicles that are currently 'in-garage' are not deleted by any process. The likelihood is that if they were left on the server earlier on, someone *may* have stolen them and chopped them for cash. Impounding doesn't destroy them; crushing does, but that should ONLY be done if the vehicle has been directly involved in the commission of a CRIME.

Now, on to the admin side. Calling an admin 'immature' or claiming 'rage ban' is never going to get you very far. You have your own opinions as to why the ban was made - they are invariably going to be different to the admin's opinion, and he (or she) will always attempt to be acting on the side of 'fair-play'. Calling them names or insulting their maturity is not likely to endear you to them, or get you a positive resolution quicker (or at all). I for one will not tolerate abuse of admins - they try VERY hard to get things right, and sometimes in extremely difficult and pressured situations. I expect an apology here, whatever the outcome. If you come back and simply say 'he was rude to me', then I shall ban you myself. Permanently. Admins *MAY* sometimes be stressed out, angry, or annoyed, as well as disappointed that they feel they've had to reach for the ban hammer. They may even comment on a player's gameplay or roleplay to an extent that the player may disagree with or find critical. I have even been known to swear at a particularly stupidly-behaved player before now. Thing is, it is the Admin's prerogative to JUDGE. Not the players. We're the ones WORKING; we're the ones attempting to interpret the RULES as best we can; you're the one PLAYING.

Now, that said, if I'm honest, I don't actually agree that this ban was ideal. To my mind, the pretext of the car-chase virtually sets up the eventual firefight RP once the vehicles are trashed and the occupants decamped. I don't think a polite discussion about tea-and-crumpets-or-else-I-shoot would have been viable. Neither do I think that texting whilst driving is viable all that much either.

However, the cops are trained to ATTEMPT to RP even before offing an escaping scrote. Sometimes to their downfall. I believe, though, that they should only attempt to do this from a position of cover and safety (to whatever degree they can) and that this places an immense burden on them. Rather like cops in real-life, sadly.

Rebels, however, are under no such obligation, and will generally shoot-to-kill if cornered. It's in their nature, and if (in circumstances like these) there has been a long running car-chase, and a final calamity that puts them on the ground, face to face with the cops, there is highly likely to be a firefight with lethal results. The cops *should* really have expected this, and be hiding behind cover if they intend to RP a capture, and/or prepared to tase, flank, restrain, or even shoot-to-kill if the rebel didn't look like playing ball. To sidle up in a car and jump out, near the rebel or in line-of-sight, I must confess, seems moderately foolhardy, if there is the slightest belief that the rebels might have weapons (which is almost a given, let's face it).

Despite what KR mentioned about having discussed this incident with admins, I've not discussed it with anyone to this detail, if at all. But he is generally correct in that when we hand out bans, USUALLY they are perma-bans, and we deal with the case here on the forums afterwards. We don't usually bother with 'timed bans' because very often the banned person will simply wait it out, and return to repeat and re-grief us all again. With a perma-ban, the 'generally good' players will actually come to the forum and make their case, and we'll sometimes turn things around for them, if they make a good one. If I'd given the ban, it would've been permanent, and dealt with here; that, I do remember discussing with KR (but had no idea it was about this incident, tbh - I lost my internet late on Friday night and wasn't back on the server till Sunday night).

So. Where does this leave us?

You're unbanned, and you have your gear - and no gear (other than that which was directly involved in the course of the crime) was lost or removed 'automatically'.

We have highlighted a 'grey area' in the rules, which I will endeavour to tighten up after discussions with Wilco (the senior admin) and the other admins. RP after SOME situations is ludicrous to expect; in others, it's essential. We have some work to do to make that easier for EVERYONE to interpret. I've already made my personal feelings clear on the daftness of 'tea-party' style roleplay at high-risk places like drug-fields or processing areas where attendees are 100-1 against being 'legal people' or 'unarmed'. Whilst this IS a serious roleplay server, I don't think that criminals engaged in serious crime in RL generally stop to chat, unless they are physically cornered and overwhelmed, out of ammo, outgunned, or whatever. Many of them will simply shoot first and ask questions later; many more of them will die. Sometimes cops will die too. Cops, however, WILL usually shout through a loud-hailer and sue for peace, but usually from a position of strength, or at least from cover. They are expected to at least ATTEMPT this (because all the civs and rebs will whine 'no RP from cops, they KOSed us', if the boot is on the other foot). But I think we need to look at relaxing that a little. If so much as ONE shot is fired at a cop (with or without it actually killing or wounding that cop), then the response must be allowed to switch immediately to 'lethal force' (if the cop wishes, but of course they can still opt to go for the tase/restrain, because that nets them a larger bounty). Or else it simply isn't 'serious roleplay'. Fair's fair.

You leave the admining stuff to the admins, and refrain from judging them or insulting them, and let them discuss their work internally, please. I want to see you apologise to KR, and demonstrate some understanding of the pressures involved, before I am happy. If you can't see that - or at least cut him and the other admins some slack - then this isn't the server you're looking for, sadly. However, I get the impression you're basically a reasonable guy, and probably a good player, caught in a tough situation, and evidently quite a good shot. We get so much RDM here, that sometimes, it's our first worry. Maybe SOME element of RP on your part would've prevented this, but I'm not going to go so far as to say it was essential, given the setup to this situation. But that doesn't give you the right to chew out an admin in public - he was just doing his job, with the ruleset he has at his disposal, and we all agree, they are NOT perfect. Everything is constantly tweaked according to experience, game-balance, exploits, griefers, and time at our disposal.

 
Mclovin - this is not the message you're looking for. Move along.

 
I can understand the pressures of being an admin and the frustration involved with new players and or trolls RDM'ing police. That being said it's also quite humiliating to be treated in such manner and then realize my actions were completely valid by current RP rules. Make no mistake - I am not trying to harass or verbally abuse anyone, just merely expressing my frustration. I have no personal agenda whatsoever to undermine Killerabbit or any other admin member that is involved with this server - In fact I was completely unaware that he was an admin at the time of my original post. 

I normally wouldn't bother making such a post (especially about a computer game) if I didn't feel so strongly that something wrong happened. Besides the obvious purpose of reversing the ban I was hoping to highlight the general confusion towards the current rules listed on this forum (even by an admin).  I think it might be really healthy for the server to elaborate the rules and somehow shove them in people's faces (perhaps on the front page of this website). I'm not trying to dictate to any admin or police force member just trying to give some feedback.

For example:
a) Only players with a rebel license are considered rebels and are allowed to follow "rebel business" like attacking cops in towns, etc. Players without a rebel license using firearms are considered RDMers. 

What difference does it make if a rebel attacks a cop in town vs just outside a town? (I was a little more than 500m outside Athira when I shot)  There are too many possibilities for misinterpretation as they are currently written.

I know that I am still confused about the 'rules of engagement' and since this incident me and my friend are avoiding any kind of play with guns to avoid the ban which mostly ruins the excitement of playing. 

Again sorry to kick up so much dust.

 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top