What's new
By:
Filters
Roleplay UK

Join the UK's biggest roleplay community on FiveM and experience endless new roleplay opportunities!

Robbing/Killing Rule Change

JackJohnson

JackJohnson

Elite
Elite Donator
Los Santos Police
Judge
Location
Scotland
Brief Summary:
Suggestion is to add a rule that stops people being robbed and dumped

Detailed Suggestion:
Essentially I would like to see rule added that would stop you killing (Fully killing them, dumping them, not just downing them) someone if you rob them, and vice versa, something along the lines of "You cannot kill a player after robbing them, unless you are forced to. If you are robbing a player or group, you cannot kill/dump the people involved where they will likely have to respawn unless you/your group are attacked".

I think the wording of the rule would need to be different but this is just an idea to stop people taking the boring approach of pocket wiping people then throwing them in the ocean to avoid any consequences. If you want to rob people, be prepared for them to remember it happen and face potential consequences. Obviously it would be different if the player being robbed tried to attack you or whatever, but just a simple robbery shouldn't end in the other party being forced to respawn because people want an easy robbery.

I know there would be a lot of grey areas with something like this and it would be difficult to judge, but just want to gather peoples opinions on this?

Hasn't happened to me, but from what I know it's happened to plenty, and it's very shit.

The Pros:
- Fair situations for everyone involved
- Chance for more prolonged RP

The Cons:
- Not sure, I'm sure people will have some cons

Does this suggestion change balance on the server ?
Yes
 
Upvote 42 Downvote
couldn't agree more. +1

Dumping Rule.

Create a rule around dumping players Dumping seems to be a quick and easy out of roleplay for quite a few people. It should be a last resort-type situation to keep roleplay going. Too many people rely on their weapons (even during the tiniest of arguments) and are very quick to dump others. If...
www.roleplay.co.uk www.roleplay.co.uk

Dumping and robbery rules

Thanks to @SteveStacyfor bringing up the subject, what i suggest are some new rules: (X.X) Dumping - Only permitted to conclude an RP story; the Water Dump resolves all ongoing feuds definitively, however, Extended feuds between groups can not be concluded via dumping. To initiate a dump, three...
www.roleplay.co.uk www.roleplay.co.uk
 
JackJohnson said:
Essentially I would like to see rule added that would stop you killing (Fully killing them, dumping them, not just downing them) someone if you rob them, and vice versa, something along the lines of "You cannot kill a player after robbing them, unless you are forced to. If you are robbing a player or group, you cannot kill/dump the people involved where they will likely have to respawn unless you/your group are attacked".
Click to expand...
I'd say you could make it like this.
You cannot kill a player you have just robbed unless they retaliate after being robbed / begin to attack / start to act hostile towards you.
E.g. If you've just been robbed you wouldnt tell the robbers "Im going to kill you" why would they let you live then.

This is a really good suggestion as it allows roleplay to happen and gets rid of the stupid behaviour where people go on the rob to just dump you after
 
Eze said:
I'd say you could make it like this.
You cannot kill a player you have just robbed unless they retaliate after being robbed / begin to attack / start to act hostile towards you.
E.g. If you've just been robbed you wouldnt tell the robbers "Im going to kill you" why would they let you live then.
Click to expand...
This sounds better yeah
 
yes, yes, yes
+1
It is way to easy to rob someone or something and getting away scot free.
This change would enable a lot more RP
 
moved to the rules part of the suggestion pages, as it's a rule change suggestion
 
+1

I agree on this, robberies happens in the real world all the time. People dont always get killed for it because off the "consequences" that might come back at you.
 
Last edited:
+1

Obviously in some rp scenarios with backstory sometimes you need to dump someone to give an end to the scenario.
But overall just the quick rob dump and kill shouldn't be a thing imo its just a pure win mentality and not enjoyable for the party involved.
 
Would this cover dumping people off the end of the pier?
 
JackJohnson said:
Brief Summary:
Suggestion is to add a rule that stops people being robbed and dumped

Detailed Suggestion:
Essentially I would like to see rule added that would stop you killing (Fully killing them, dumping them, not just downing them) someone if you rob them, and vice versa, something along the lines of "You cannot kill a player after robbing them, unless you are forced to. If you are robbing a player or group, you cannot kill/dump the people involved where they will likely have to respawn unless you/your group are attacked".

I think the wording of the rule would need to be different but this is just an idea to stop people taking the boring approach of pocket wiping people then throwing them in the ocean to avoid any consequences. If you want to rob people, be prepared for them to remember it happen and face potential consequences. Obviously it would be different if the player being robbed tried to attack you or whatever, but just a simple robbery shouldn't end in the other party being forced to respawn because people want an easy robbery.

I know there would be a lot of grey areas with something like this and it would be difficult to judge, but just want to gather peoples opinions on this?

Hasn't happened to me, but from what I know it's happened to plenty, and it's very shit.

The Pros:
- Fair situations for everyone involved
- Chance for more prolonged RP

The Cons:
- Not sure, I'm sure people will have some cons

Does this suggestion change balance on the server ?
Yes
Click to expand...
This makes alot of sense, IRL robbing someone and murdering them are 2 completely separate trains of thought, some serious escalation between robbing and then completely killing them for what a couple smoothies and a shitty gun just because you don't want any comeback from it?

I feel like the comeback from robbing someone is what would create alot more interesting storylines and prevent the braindead actions of just thinking fuck it lets rob this guy his gang etc won't find out because we'll just dump the geezer, BIG +1
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top