Report a Player - Muthay - Poor/Low Quality RP (Rejected)

[Leaping Lizards]

Your In-game name

Alfa Kenibodi

Name of the player(s) you are reporting

Muthay

Date of the incident

07/13/2017

Time of the incident (GMT)

10

What best describes this incident ?

Poor/Low Quality RP

Which server did the incident take place on

Server 1

Please (in detail) describe the incident

Me and my friend got into an accident just outside of Kavala. I was waiting for the police to come. Then this random man from the street started to RP with me. He kept trying to tell me that he wants to ease my pain and execute me and I kept telling him that I am ok, I will be helped soon. I told him I have a family to live for and that it is not my time to go, but he still insisted that he would take the pain away. Finally he executed me as the police were 100 meters away. The police revived my friend and I was forced to start a new life in Athira. I tried getting Muthay into teamspeak but he kept trying to justify in that he RP'd his way into executing me so he did not need to come into teamspeak.

Link to any evidence (Youtube/Screenshot)

https://youtu.be/386xn-ZSFzU
This report is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth!

Yes

You tried to resolve the situation with the player(s) before reporting

Yes

This is not a revenge report (Abuse will lead to forum/community bans)

Yes

 

[muthay]

I don't see how that was Poor/Low Quality RP by me when I roleplayed with you more than it is shown in the video, and how could you possibily know that the police is coming if there was no friend of your calling them and when I refused to call them, which means that you were metagaming by saying that they are coming just because you saw how far away the policeman actually was. You even said that the medic "went back to bed" as soon as he logged off as seen in the video, well then, how could you know that the medic "went back to bed" ? 

 

[Leaping Lizards]

But you knew there was no medics on duty which gave you a reason to execute me 

 

[muthay]

I am not going to reply anymore to this report as this seems a revenge report to me. I will answer only if someone from the staff asks for it.

 

[LONG BEARD]

I am not going to reply anymore to this report as this seems a revenge report to me. I will answer only if someone from the staff asks for it.

What incidents have occurred prior to this that makes you believe it's a revenge report?

In addition, whilst the actual chat RP was decent, executing a stranger to put him out of his misery when he's pleading with you not to is exceptionally poor.  What was your quality roleplay reason for doing this?

 

[muthay]

To be honest I think I got a little mad when he started to metagame, as seen in the video I even asked him "How can you tell" after I told him that there are no medics on duty at which he said "Yes there is" and as soon as the medic went offline he said "Ok, nevermind he went back to bed" and started to ask me to call the police. He never stated that someone called for the police or medics to help him, he started to talk about them "coming" only because he saw how far away they were. He could of roleplay better than he did and make me rethink my decision of ending his misery, but he didn't, he kept on saying that they are coming, pretty much metagame, when he could of just say that someone called the police for help and they are coming. We both could of roleplay that situation much better.

 

[LONG BEARD]

And saying there are no medics on duty isn't the same thing? You did tried to backtrack by saying you went to the hospital and there was no one there. Fact is, it's a big island. Without looking to see how many medics were online you'd have no way to know if there was any patrolling the island in their vehicles which on an island this size, we have to assume there always is, even if it's just fictional.  I really don't see the difference here.

This isn't about the metagaming at this stage of the report, we'll deal with that later.

Are you still of the opinion that you did nothing wrong and that executing strangers at the side of the road, who you've no business with, and on the basis of 'putting them out of their misery' is acceptable / quality role-play?

You've also not answered my question about the accusation made about this being a revenge report.

 

[muthay]

                                                                                                                                                                                                             @SI LONG BEARD

I know that an execution must be carried out with high quality roleplay so thats why I tried to roleplay with him. Fact is that I got executed a few times by strangers on the side of the road who had no business with me and I thought that if they roleplay even if they didn't had something to do with me being gunned down, in a car accident etc. , they are allowed to do it even if I tell them not to.

Maybe I need to read again the rules of the server as I haven't in a month or so to see if there are any changes and to update my knowledge on the rules of the server and do better in the future.

At the moment of the incident he didn't say anything about wanting any compensation or atleast I do not recall it, he just wanted me to come teamspeak and I said to him that I don't think I did something wrong which is why I didn't go to teamspeak. About the revenge report I think it is just because I didn't want to go to teamspeak. If I really broke any server rule I should be punished and I will try my best in the future if I am given an other chance.

 

[LONG BEARD]

Okay.

Revenge report is a serious accusation, hence why I pressed you on it.. You not going to TS means you left Alfa no option but to make a forum report. You could possibly have resolved it in TS and avoided this. This is not a revenge report, lets make that clear. Regardless of whether you think you are in the right, you are always advised to try and resolve the issue on TS. 

You are correct, execution should be carried out with high quality RP, and "I'm putting you out of your misery" is far from high quality RP. You are essentially taking advantage of someone who has no ability to defend himself or fight back. There was a high chance he could have been revived given the fact he was injured in a highly populated area by the side of the road.  

Now to the metagaming. Both of you did metagame police / medic situation. Please don't use it in RP again. It's for you as a player to know, not your character in game.

Finally @muthay, I have had a good look through your chat logs to get an idea of the type of player you are. I feel in this instance, a warning will suffice and I believe you will learn from this and ensure it doesn't happen again.  I will be placing a warning on your account which will be taken heavily into consideration should you find yourself reported for a future infringement. 

Learn from this please and lets not see you in here again!