Report a player - 202 (member of cutlass) - GTA RP

[O4rZ]

Server: GTA RP
Your Character Name: Jason Astral
Reported Players: 202 (member of cutlass)
Date: Jun 19, 2024
Time: 23:20
What best describes this incident: NVL and Failure to Roleplay injuries
Please (in detail) describe the incident: In this clip provided, at the very start you see myself and my friend pull up on a man getting into his car, we have our weapons out and ask him to step back out the vehicle, with two weapons on him. He then proceeds to try to shoot my friend who quickly shoots back in defence. This is not how we had planned for it to go, so we decided to take him to the dodgy doctor, so that we could take his firearm. At 2:10 in the clip We provided medical attention on the way to find the dodgy doc and he was good throughout, roleplaying injuries. That was until we got to the dodgy and revived him.
At this point 15:30 The man is defibbed and holds his hands straight up, as again he has to guns on him. As I move forward to search him and begin searching, he shots my friend and aims at me, combat rolling and shooting again. This man had JUST been defibbed and after roleplaying injuries to his head and ‘seeing the light’ he is up and rolling around. (Fair play on the shot). This is where I feel rule break G4.5 has been broken as he has re-entered a combat situation straight away and not continued to roleplay the injuries he had been prior to the defibrillator.
We did go to QE, but I feel this wasn’t resolved and we had to agree to disagree.
Link(s) To Any Evidence:

To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Accept third party cookies

 

[Macca]

Hello mate, sad to see its come to this considering we talked about this in Liaison and you and I were both happy about the situation and that we thought it had been resolved, first thing id like to point out is the part in this report where you said and I quote "we have our weapons out and ask him to step out the vehicle" now from this clip I can only see one person step out the car with a weapon drawn at me while your still sat in the car twiddling your thumbs, also the bit where you say "with two weapons pointed at him" again from what I can see in this clip I can only see one weapon and i took my chances which didn't go my way, now to the part at the dodgy, other than that we both agreed that me not rolling and running after being revived was completely fine, yes you see me role as i shoot you, on my side of things I got stuck on your friends body as I killed him and swivelled to you so I tried to get myself unstuck and rolled as I was still aiming in, now the other thing id like to point out is that its a 1v1 against me and the other guy, you decided to search me so I took my chance with him and dropped him then took you out too, as I said to you in the liaison call its a 1v1 if you had both had guns to me I would have complied and dropped my stuff but you decided to check me first which was silly. other than that I don't have a clip from my pov of things as my medal wasn't running at this time, just leaving that as a little heads up for staff when they look at this.

that's all from me for now

 

[OllieWollie]

I was the other guy in this situation, would just like to add this other clip which shows the guy on the floor "seeing stars" and "the light getting brighter and closer" https://medal.tv/games/gta-v/clips/i6rNXktuHCBk2mnXw/d13374w5hIWG?invite=cr-MSxsaGosMjI4NTEzMDk3LA having just been shot in the head 4 times i can understand these statements, but i felt forced to get you up as you were stating these things. you were responsive in the car but as soon as we got there and said we were waiting for a couple more people, you instantly went unresponsive again. However as soon as you are up, you are rolling around on the floor, aiming perfectly, able to talk absolutely fine and not sounding injured, driving fine etc.

 

[Logan]

Hi. Thanks for the report. Had a look into this one and came to the following conclusions:

The first incident, the alleged NVL where you and a friend park beside the player, your friend approaches him, and a shooting unfolds.
Only 1 weapon was pointed at him, he was clearly already armed with the firearm inside the car as you can see it on him as he exits the vehicle and begins shooting to defend himself.
He seen an opportunity to catch his attacker off guard with a pistol he had, and he did. He just didn't survive it which is entirely on him for taking such a risk. This is not a breach of NVL, he was not clearly outnumbered nor at an obvious disadvantage.

Moving on, it would have been good to have seen a bit better of quality with your RP whilst injured @Macca . You may have still been roleplaying whilst injured, but it wasn't very high quality was it. Please improve on this. Also, the complaint that has originated from this report is of course he did not roleplay his injuries very well however, Jason, you's have stated he was shot in the head 4 times. If I was roleplaying that I shot someone in the head 4 times, I don't think I'd expect them to be very audible for the next 15-20 minutes.

The final alleged rulebreak, NVL again: Once you have gotten the doctor to revive the player, you begin searching his pockets whilst he has his gun on him. Just like the beginning there is now only 1 person holding him at gunpoint. If he draws his gun, it's a coin flip essentially. And he did. He drew his gun, your friend missed his shots and he's gotten lucky and came out on top of the fight. No NVL breach here. Had you have been more careful and strategic, this might have had a different outcome.

DECLINED