What's new
By:
Filters
Roleplay UK

Join the UK's biggest roleplay community on FiveM and experience endless new roleplay opportunities!

Killing NHS Members in the Red Zone

When would you consider killing a NHS Medic in the Red Zone?

  • Whenever I get the opportunity.

    Votes: 11 7.9%

  • Only when he is ignoring my orders, such as DNR's or refusing to help me.

    Votes: 59 42.4%

  • Never as they are here to help.

    Votes: 69 49.6%
  • Total voters
    139
CMO Marc Smith said:
Not going to say too much here as I haven't had much of a chance to play recently so don't even know how bad things are for medics in red zone... but a lot of these suggestions regarding uniforms / vehicles open up the opportunity for the tactical response branch to be started. If you can get the new stuff implemented and that's what NHS command wants at least... I know it's what we wanted previously.

Specific training and equipment allowing you to stay at your safest in a dangerous location, still allowing you to do your jobs by extracting injured people back to a hospital / clinic.

Personally, I'd love to see the branch implemented, and the ingame equipment was all we were waiting for ;) And actually, seeing that implemented might be what brings me back to the NHS at some point, new stuff is fun :p

- Marc
Click to expand...
100% agreed new stuff is fun :D

 
AlanB said:
https://ihl-databases.icrc.org/applic/ihl/ihl.nsf/ART/365-570030?OpenDocument

It is a Geneva war crime to knowingly engage against an unarmed individual clearly bearing insignia. (Caduceus)

As such, organized groups should condemn the engaging of these personnel under fear of being labeled as terrorists and engaged as such.

Medics are not armed personnel and they should be treated as such - they are of no threat to any individual and there are many other options than killing them. However, NHS are not trained combat medics and as such, should not be openly given authorization to enter an active warzone. If possible, it could be looked into that a new specialization is brought into the NHS specifically for this role. By all RP standards, they would not be NHS agents but in fact government-supported medical specialists trained in combat medicine.

brb i'll write up a suggestions document.

tl;dr -

no they should not be "allowed" in,
no they should not be punished severely,
yes they can be killed but its' really REALLY bad to do and people really shouldn't do it,
make new rank/specialization for combat medicine (see suggestion document)
Click to expand...
It would be great if on killing a medic in the NHS faction instead of "you are now wanted for murder/manslaughter" you got "You are now wanted for War Crimes!"

Could be good in the sense:

  • Serious crime above murder, big big compulsory fines + max jail time
  • If rebels leave said redzone and are scanned by police - a war criminal could add some top lvl RP
  • Possible Police NCA/War Criminal 'Special Court' RP after War Criminals arrest - make a public example of war criminals
  • If medics had the ability to see 'war criminals' they can refuse to render medical aid (maybe?)
Could be bad in the sense:

  • "Hurr durr I'll kill this medic for a £2mil bounty and be a war criminal"
 
They way i see it ( from a non medic player point of view ) is that putting rules and restrictions on nhs/police in general is a negative. People join the nhs for RP. One would assume that going into the red zone to get involved in a roleplay revive would be a bad idea. Why put restrictions on people wasting there own time.

 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top