What's new
Roleplay UK

Join the UK's biggest roleplay community on FiveM and experience endless new roleplay opportunities!

Report a player - Changaloas (Not sure of individual names, sorry) - GTA RP

Fireman Sam

Los Santos Police
Los Santos Police
Los Santos NHS
Los Santos NHS Training
Los Santos Senior Firefighter
Solicitor
Location
uk

Server: GTA RP
Your Character Name: Banjo Johnson
Reported Players: Changaloas (Not sure of individual names, sorry)
Date: Aug 20, 2024
Time: 21:45
What best describes this incident: G1.2 - RDM
Please (in detail) describe the incident: Just for some background, yesterday I was crewed up with Harrison Wilsworth and Kieren Clark on a CID patrol. Then a call came in from an employee at Benny's talking about a gang member having a gun. So we responded as seen in the evidence from Kieren Clark. As we arrived on scene we assitained all the relevant RP info we needed before moving in. Someone from inside also identified the person for us so myself and Harrison moved in with seperate officer following behind. We then detained the suspect however the individual claimed he couldnt see us in LOOC. So we took him outside and all of a sudden lots of war cars from the OCG Changaloas turned up. They made demands to get him out of cuffs however within the space of 10 seconds both myself and Harrison Wilsworth were gunned down. Then followed by the other officer and Kieren Clark.

The annoying part is the fact within a space of 10 seconds, myself and Harrison were dead. Yes they said get him out of cuffs but other than that there was no warning or any prior roleplay with any of the other members. Also the fact they were just saying "Get him out of cuffs" and "I suggest you get him out of cuffs", doesn't seem to provide excellent RP. I understand that they dont want their friend arrested but they just shout a few times then gun us down. Within the the rule G1.2 it states that: “Put your hands up or I will shoot” and countdowns are not considered quality roleplay, please at least attempt to create an interesting roleplay story before considering violence. They gave similar few worded instuctions and then went straight to violence. There was no real development at all. Futhermore the guy who shot me just turned around and said "Fuck you all" then stepped out and shot us. Even something as simple as pulling guns on us and telling us to get him out of cuffs I believe would have been moire sufficent than killing 4 cops.

Finally I can only say sorry for the suspect who apparently, couldnt see us but at the time we didnt know so we took him outside and then before trying to resolve any of this we were killed.
Link(s) To Any Evidence: Kieren Clarks perspective and follow up:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
My perspective as one of the detaining officers:
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.
 
Good evening all, I will be responding to this report on behalf of Changaloas as I was directly involved in the situation.

Firstly, it's a shame no liaison was called regarding this as I would have been able to outline the exact reasons for why this played out the way it did. Seems like it's becoming more and more frequent that liaison's are not called for in OOC or LOOC which is unfortunate not just for us players but also staff. Regardless I will continue anyway.

You didn't request a chat in liaison and have posted this report borderline on 24 hours (can't remember exactly what time it was) after this situation happened which means clips and session recordings have been deleted but I will gather what I can from my side.

I would like to mention quickly before I get into what actually happened at Benny's is your dispatch message. The exact words recieved on your dispatch was "some gang member wearing brown has a gun on me." No risk assessment was conducted on route considering "gang member" and "gun" was mentioned. Not sure if this is something that takes place in Police or not but personally it looks like you jumped into the deep end with no thoughts on how you would swim out. I would of thought that potential outcomes would be discussed or just anything to get your officers on the same page if things were to go wrong. With this not happening it leads to moments like at 2:49 of Kieren's clip where it sounds like one of the officers is taking a stroll in the park? Considering a gang member and gun is involved is quite crazy. Secondly, no comm to firearms on route to better prepare for what could take place with this gang member and gun? Would have set you up a lot better but what do I know.

So it all starts by a member of Changaloas (Inferno) being arrested inside the premises of Benny's, he states in LOOC that he cannot see anything inside the building while this is taking place (we as a gang obviously do not know this at the time) but I would like to point to the fact straight away, after finding this out was you going to uncuff him to treat him fairly and make sure it was fun for all parties or just going to arrest him and sort it out after the fact? It's quite disappointing to find this out afterwards as surely uncuffing him for the fact that he couldn't see anything would be enough but also the multiple requests from me and my fellow gang members shortly after arriving would have crossed your mind? - not 1 word was said from your side after multiple people and multiple requests from our side which is becoming more and more frequent every single day from Police and in my opinion I just think it's so poor to not be able to have a conversation while a situation is going down, we are here to roleplay after all. At this point there was plenty of RP to be had if you had let him go which is the real shame here.

Anyway as Inferno is being escorted out of the property I am coming up the road and I tell the boys that are already at Benny's to tell the officers to take him out of cuffs. Looking at the clips there is a total of 4 officers but regardless a total of 6+ Brown coloured cars (which you described yourself as "war cars") appear on scene almost instantly. I would like to take note at this point of rules G2.4 and C1.7. In regards to G2.4 we completely outnumbered your cars 6+ to 2 and would of been an unknown amount of members in our 6+ cars but again this was not communicated or roleplayed by any officers before or after our requests were made. I will repeat what I said before as I think this is extremely relevant. 0 words was exchanged from your side after 7 CLEAR requests, (from your POV) 3 from Sultan, 3 from 9F and 1 from Neo to take our member out of cuffs. Why was there no effort to make conversation? And why when we are trying to start roleplaying with you is the first thing you do is call for firearms? You were ambushed and instead of complying and going forward with the RP hoping other units would respond to panics, you have made an effort to "win" the situation with a radio call before fully finding out the situation you was in. We're literally talking to you and you choose to ignore us, press panic buttons and call for firearms backup?? It's just so poor. You can even hear one of our most experienced RP members astonished when we hear the call for firearms before any officer interacting with us. You basically backed us into a corner with what options we could take next and in that moment my thoughts was that you have quite literally taken the piss with ignorance and are not untouchable hence the "fuck you all" proceeding with shots fired.

You have said this:
Even something as simple as pulling guns on us and telling us to get him out of cuffs I believe would have been moire sufficent than killing 4 cops.
If you would have replied to any of us and had the intention to roleplay this somewhat would of occurred next. You haven't said a word other than calling for backup and expect us to let you waste time by standing at your car with guns as if 6+ Brown "war cars" surrounding and 7 sincere requests wasn't already a big enough threat. This is where I think C1.7 is to be taken note of, do we all have to get out of our cars and come to yours with guns or should you recognise what's going on and that you was already in big danger if you didn't uncuff him. Play stupid games and you win stupid prizes is the only thing which comes to mind here. Police already know for a fact that Changaloas and Marabunta are in war and that these are times of high hostility, we definitely would have guns on us and knowing that any moment Mara could fly around the corner (we are actively looking for them when our POV starts) are factors that play into us staying in our cars rather than poking our guns through your window just to get a word of conversation.

You have also said this:
Yes they said get him out of cuffs but other than that there was no warning or any prior roleplay with any of the other members.
At 2:05 in Kieren's POV another member of Changaloas (clearly wearing the same brown gang vest) comms on radio that one of our members is being hands'd up at Benny's which is where the prior roleplay starts, not sure if you've watched your own clips that you've posted? Kieren Clarks does not communicate this with other officers, which is not our issue. This same Changaloa member then continues to chat to Kieren from 2:20 until 2:48 and is very inquisitive as to what's going on inside and his friend's wellbeing. This 28 second chat and the radio comm should ring alarm bells should it not? Still no communication to the other officers though.

In the eyes of Changaloas, Police are already in I guess what you would call "bad books" due to the majority of fights we've had with Marabunta they are always getting taken to the local doctor but when we get snatched by Police from a gang fight we are always arrested and sent away. This is all part of the context with what I've written above as to where my frustration comes from in this situation.

Lastly I would like to make sure this is clear from our end that we as a gang was NOT looking for a gunfight, we simply wanted our member and to leave which is shown at the end of the clip I've provided. We did not pick up any of the downed Police we just took our member and left which can easily be continued in roleplay. At the end of the day we are a gang and we are mid war with another gang, our strategy in general is methodical but to the point, you had no strategy and was not prepared in the slightest for what could happen or did happen. Your comms and set up was a shambles and if you really wanted to do well in this situation you would have set your self up better to do so and not be ignorant and act like arresting a gang member in front of his gang is a walk in the park.

FULL POV from our side - https://medal.tv/?contentId=ivWnV6sRrQMhRN26c&invite=cr-MSxyODEsMjE1MzkyNDQs&spok=d1337KevZGmE

Inferno not being able to see anything inside Benny's -
To view this content we will need your consent to set third party cookies.
For more detailed information, see our cookies page.

Thank you to the staff member(s) that take this report and apologies for the lengthy reply but I hope this is enough to cover all aspects of this situation.
 
Last edited:
Sorry I have a couple of other short points I would like to make as I didn't want to go over character limit above.

there was no warning
Seemed to be enough warning to call for Firearms. And I assume Firearms wasn't coming for a tea party.

"Get him out of cuffs" and "I suggest you get him out of cuffs", doesn't seem to provide excellent RP.
You and your officers not being at all afraid of arresting a gang member in front of his gang that outnumber you and are shouting demands at you is not realistic nor quality RP.

I understand that they dont want their friend arrested but they just shout a few times then gun us down.
I hope by reading my first response you can see that you was gunned down for reasons far beyond not wanting him arrested.

Within the the rule G1.2 it states that: “Put your hands up or I will shoot” and countdowns are not considered quality roleplay, please at least attempt to create an interesting roleplay story before considering violence.
You was not counted down or even told you was going to be shot?? While on this point it's not necessary to tell someone they will be shot before shooting them which I guess is what you was waiting to be told and also why you think this is RDM. This has all happened due to you being incompetent at roleplaying your situation correctly. Also did we not attempt to create a roleplay story before you called for firearms?

There was no real development at all
Did you miss where you called for Firearms right in front of us instead of engaging in the demands. If that hasn't developed the situation at all then I don't know what to say.

Futhermore the guy who shot me just turned around and said "Fuck you all" then stepped out and shot us. Even something as simple as pulling guns on us and telling us to get him out of cuffs I believe would have been moire sufficent than killing 4 cops.
You have called firearms in to what can only be to engage with us and are arresting our gang member in front of us at a public mechanic shop that has a lot of traffic going in and out and probably many camera's, are we stupid enough to brandish X amount of firearms out in the open at one of the busiest spots in city? Time is of the essence and because of the radio comm to firearms and also anyone from the public potentially informing Mara we was there it needed to be swift. I suppose you haven't had a crim character before so you wouldn't know what these problems are like.


Very last point I'm making which I think multiple groups have had problems with before is that situations like this with some Police/G6 massively affects a gang's roleplay at times and makes it look low quality, it's a shame because sometimes you have to lower your roleplay to the standard you are presented with. And it's not all Police/G6, the majority are very good at what they do, it's just a select few individuals and situations. If this situation would of continued the way it should of we would of hopefully took an officer, questioned him in regards to why Inferno was arrested and so much more roleplay could have come from that. Let alone the more than likely chase directly afterwards that probably would of ensued if the 4 officers we shot was alive to inform the officers responding to the panic's.

I will not be responding no more unless instructed by a staff member to do so. Thanks for your time and I hope you all have a good end to the week.

Mazza
 
Firstly, I want to say that sorry there was no liason and I should have tried to just contact you guys so I'm sorry. At the time I just went a long with the consequences as I was 100% sure. Admittedly the RP from our side was pretty poor as well.

Referring to the part where he claimed he couldn't see us, my honest thought was that Harrison was gonna take him outside like said in the clip to sort it out but we were instantly pulled up on. I will also say that (although not great RP from us) for me somewhat panic mode set in. Looking back now if I was to do anything different I would have definitely have just let go of your friend and or tried to communicate better. But alas we can't change the past.

I think with you guys clearing it up in your replies has provided the understanding I needed and I want to stress that I am sorry for not trying to liase with you guys.

I believe with your insight from the situation this seems resolved and I don't want to pursue any action from this.
 
Staff could you close this please :)
 
I'm glad you managed to resolve this, took me a while to scroll so thank god I didn't have to read all that 😅

Report Declined - Issue Resolved
 
Back
Top